dir. Jonathan Mostow
U-571 is one of those war thrillers that’s best approached as fiction with a military haircut. It’s brisk, well-mounted, and moderately gripping, but it plays faster with history than with torpedo triggers. The film takes inspiration from a real 1941 British naval operation—disabling a German U-boat, boarding it via a disguised rescue vessel, and retrieving an Enigma machine—but hands the credit to American sailors, which, to put it gently, didn’t sit well with historians on either side of the Atlantic. Matthew McConaughey plays Lt. Andrew Tyler, a junior officer with a clean jawline and limited command experience, selected for a covert mission mainly because he speaks fluent German. His arc is standard-issue: early doubt, moral conflict, eventual steeliness. At first, he struggles to assert authority, but there’s never much doubt he’ll grow into the uniform by reel three. His commanding officer (Bill Paxton) sets the tone with starchy resolve, and Harvey Keitel lends his usual no-nonsense gravitas as the grizzled chief. The mission itself unfolds with underwater cat-and-mouse tension—depth charges, flooding compartments, suspicious sonar echoes. The espionage element gives the film a layer of intrigue, though it’s often steamrolled by more conventional action beats: countdowns, explosions, terse shouting in narrow hallways. Submarine films almost always flirt with claustrophobia, and Mostow gets the atmosphere right—tight quarters, sweat, desperation—but never quite pushes it into psychological territory. For history buffs, the film’s narrative sleight-of-hand is more than a minor irritation. But as genre entertainment, it holds together. There’s enough technical detail to give the illusion of accuracy, and enough suspense to keep things moving at a steady clip. It’s not Das Boot, but it’s not a misfire either. U-571 might fumble the facts, but it delivers the tension. Just don’t mistake it for a history lesson unless you’re prepared to annotate.
Starring: Matthew McConaughey, Bill Paxton, Harvey Keitel, Jon Bon Jovi, David Keith, Thomas Kretschmann, Jake Weber, Jack Noseworthy, Thomas Guiry, Will Estes, T.C. Carson.
Rated PG-13. Universal Pictures. USA-France. 116 mins.