dir. Tim Fywell
I Capture the Castle is a film that understands how to look beautiful in candlelight but struggles to say much when the lights come up. This adaptation of Dodie Smith’s novel gets the atmosphere right—the lichen-covered walls, the damp stone corridors, the rusting remnants of aristocracy now reduced to theatrical routine. The Mortmain family occupies a crumbling castle like they’re performing genteel poverty as dinner theater, half-starved and half-amused by their own irrelevance. James Mortmain (Bill Nighy), once a literary darling, now floats through his days in a fog—scribbling nothing and snapping at anyone who reminds him of it. His second wife Topaz (Tara Fitzgerald) is more artwork than character, all ethereal twirls and emotional drift. Holding it all together, if just barely, is Cassandra (Romola Garai), the teenage daughter who observes everything, writes most of it down, and says only what she can’t keep to herself. Her narration cuts through the softness—dry, self-aware, and occasionally so sharp it startles. Early scenes have a flicker of unpredictability, a sort of fidgety rhythm that suits the characters. But once the plot arrives—a pair of American brothers (Henry Thomas and Marc Blucas) who’ve inherited the estate and show up with good intentions and passable hair—the film settles into more conventional postures. Rose (Rose Byrne), Cassandra’s older sister, sees in Simon (Thomas) a ticket out of faded grandeur and launches a campaign of charm offensive. Cassandra, quietly and without strategy, begins to fall for him too. It’s not quite a triangle—more an ache that hides behind good manners and the edges of her diary. The film doesn’t botch its romantic elements, but it doesn’t quite animate them either. What ought to feel emotionally fraught plays more like a well-dressed rehearsal. The restraint is probably faithful to the novel’s tone, but on screen, it often scans as undercooked. Garai, thankfully, is vivid throughout. Her Cassandra is curious, vulnerable, and funny in a way that never seems forced. She’s the reason it works at all. The rest of the cast does what they can—Nighy especially, chewing through his silences—but the film never builds to anything emotionally sharp enough to match its production design. It just looks nice. Still, if you like your literary cinema overcast and gently tragic, there’s enough here to admire. The music swells in all the right places, the dresses waft, and the candlelight works overtime. But there’s more polish than pulse. A story of longing that forgets, occasionally, to ache.
Starring: Romola Garai, Henry Thomas, Rose Byrne, Bill Nighy, Tara Fitzgerald, Marc Blucas, Henry Cavill, Sinéad Cusack.
Rated R. Momentum Pictures. UK. 117 mins.