dir. Jared Hess
Jack Black, in all his soft-skulled, high-octane glory, dons the spandex of Ignacio—a humble Mexican monk with culinary aspirations by day and a penchant for secret, sinful lucha libre by night. The monastery kitchen doesn’t pay much, and the orphans deserve better soup, so he slips away in a cape and stretchy pants to body-slam for pesos. The problem—according to ecclesiastical rules and possibly divine precedent—is that professional wrestling is a sin. That’s the set-up, and it’s a pretty good one: a holy fool risking damnation for dignity. As a follow-up to Napoleon Dynamite, Nacho Libre arrives already bearing the weight of expectations. However, under that weight, it buckles. The Hesses retain their signature deadpan delivery, framing characters like paper dolls in wide, awkward compositions, but this time the tone doesn’t quite cast the same hypnotic spell. There’s a strain behind the silliness, as if the film is working harder to earn our laughter and, paradoxically, achieving slightly less of it. The gags feel more calculated, the absurdism a bit more self-conscious—less the found-object charm of Napoleon and more like something bought secondhand and spray-painted zany. Jack Black, for his part, is a walking contradiction to the film’s house style. He commits with the fervor of a man headlining an arena tour—leaping, screeching, mugging, and throwing his whole diaphragm into the role. It’s a bravely ridiculous performance, and often quite funny, but he’s a comedian built for operatic excess, not stifled awkwardness. You can feel the incongruent juxtaposition where his instinct for full-throated chaos meets the film’s preference for blank-faced eccentricity. Oddly, it’s Héctor Jiménez, as Nacho’s skeletal tag partner and spiritual foil, who hits the comic sweet spot. He moves like a string puppet cursed with awareness, delivers his lines with the wearied calm of someone who’s seen things he refuses to name, and lands nearly every moment he’s given with impeccable, oxygen-starving deadpan. He doesn’t push; he lets the weirdness rise like dough. Despite its tonal mismatches and occasional flops, Nacho Libre remains affable and weirdly warm. There’s an innocence to it, under the fart jokes and wrestling tights—a belief that ridiculousness, pursued with conviction, can carry a kind of grace. And while the laughs come in more sporadic waves than in Napoleon Dynamite, they’re still there, tucked into odd corners, peeking out of the wrestling ring ropes, or hiding in Jiménez’s magnificent stillness. You might not laugh as hard as you want to. But if you have a taste for the eccentric, you’ll probably laugh anyway.
Starring: Jack Black, Ana de la Reguera, Héctor Jiménez, Silver King, Carla Jimenez, Richard Montoya, Enrique Muñoz, Moisés Arias, Troy Gentile.
Rated PG. Paramount Pictures. USA-Mexico. 92 mins.