dir. Charlie Bean
It’s really not bad, but it’s more subdued than it probably should be. Disney’s live-action redo of Lady and the Tramp isn’t among their worst—it’s no Pinocchio—but it still lands in that now-familiar remake zone where everything feels strangely cautious and a little too polished. The story follows the original closely. Lady is a pampered cocker spaniel living the good life—fancy house, doting owners, and not a care in the world. Then a baby shows up, and suddenly she’s not the center of attention anymore. One misunderstanding leads to another, and before long she’s muzzled, chased, and out on the street. That’s where she meets Tramp, a scruffy stray who’s made a lifestyle out of not getting attached. They wander the city, dodge trouble, eat spaghetti in an alley, and—against all odds—start to fall for each other. It’s not a bad setup, but the mood is off. The lighting is dim, the pacing slow, and the supposedly emotional moments come and go without much feeling. There’s a sense the film is trying to mean something, but it never quite gets there. Even the romance feels like it’s just running through familiar motions, without anything new underneath. It’s also a little too heavy for kids. The dog pound scenes are uncomfortably bleak, and the overall tone is quieter and more downcast than the story really needs. Probably why Disney sent it straight to streaming—it looks good on the homepage, and longtime fans might give it a glance, but that’s about it. It’s a handsome remake with nowhere to go—watchable in the moment, forgettable five minutes later, and unlikely to mean much to anyone who wasn’t already in love with the original.
Voices of: Tessa Thompson, Justin Theroux, Sam Elliott, Janelle Monáe, Benedict Wong, Ashley Jensen. Starring: Kiersey Clemons, Thomas Mann, Yvette Nicole Brown, Adrian Martinez.
Rated PG. Walt Disney Studios. USA. 103 mins.