dir. Norman Foster
A frontier love story trimmed to studio scale, Rachel and the Stranger plays like a fireside folktale with just enough grit to hold attention. William Holden is David Harvey, a recently widowed settler who purchases the indenture of Rachel (Loretta Young), a soft-spoken woman working off her father’s debts. He marries her, technically—more arrangement than affection—so it won’t seem improper to house her under the same roof. She cooks, cleans, teaches his son, and lives in the same cabin, though never quite as a wife. Rachel, for her part, plays it straight. No coquetry, no protest. She does the job. Enter Jim Fairways (Robert Mitchum), a scruffy, itinerant hunter who blows through like wind through a smokehouse. He sizes up Rachel, flashes a grin, and makes himself very comfortable. David, predictably, stiffens. A triangle forms—hesitant, unspoken, and unmistakable. And just beyond it, the threat of the Shawnee hangs in the air like dense moisture—present, pressing, and hard to ignore. (Whether you can stomach the stock Hollywood depiction of Native Americans is another matter.) It’s not a grand film, but it moves well and resolves with a satisfying snap. The budget’s modest, but the cast makes it work—Holden all flinty reserve, Mitchum in full backwoods flirt, and Young with a patience that plays stronger than it looks. It was the studio’s biggest hit that year—unexpected, maybe, but not undeserved.
Starring: Loretta Young, William Holden, Robert Mitchum, Gary Gray.
Not Rated. RKO Pictures. USA. 80 mins.