dir. Tate Taylor
The premise arrives with promise: high schoolers scrounging for alcohol stumble upon a lonely woman with a stash and a basement. From this chance encounter, a fragile arrangement is born. She’s Sue Ann—though soon enough they start calling her Ma, because that’s what horror loves: a name that disarms before the knife comes out. She invites them to drink, to dance, to shriek themselves stupid in the safety of her cellar. At first, she’s an icon of permissive cool. Then she lingers too long. Then the texts get weird—photos with her face awkwardly pasted into their group shots, messages that swing from clingy to menacing. Octavia Spencer, relieved of her usual moral gravitas, tears into the role with gusto. She plays Sue Ann as someone twitching with unspent adolescence, weaponizing maternal warmth with the precision of a scalpel. You get the sense the film wants to let her spiral—really spiral—into something wicked and unhinged. She’s ready. The script, alas, is not. The tonal calibration is off—chronically. The pacing limps when it should pounce. Suspense dissolves into repetition, and the film’s “slow reveal” of Sue Ann’s trauma plays less like descent than stalling. We’re told she was humiliated in high school. Now she wants the popular kids’ kids to pay. But the moment where Ma tips from wounded to monstrous never quite lands. Instead, we’re handed actions: stalking, drugging, cutting, branding. Startling, yes. But not rooted in anything that deepens our dread. Taylor’s direction sets up scenes like it’s working from a checklist: teen rivalry, check. Hidden photos, check. Basement dungeon, check. But the connective tissue—the character logic, the moral spiral—is slack. Even Ma’s twisted “care” for her daughter, suggestive of Munchausen by Proxy, gets treated with the same cursory glance as her party-planning. Nothing coheres. Threads dangle. Spencer still manages to find something sharper—something sadder—in the margins. You can almost see the movie that might’ve been: a grotesque fable about buried trauma, adolescent cruelty, and what happens when the discarded refuse to stay forgotten. But what we get can’t decide whether it wants to be a campy cautionary tale, a social revenge thriller, or Misery in a beer koozie. The result is a horror film without atmosphere, built around a character with too much potential and nowhere to go.
Starring: Octavia Spencer, Diana Silvers, McKaley Miller, Corey Fogelmanis, Juliette Lewis, Luke Evans, Gianni Paolo, Dante Brown, Missi Pyle, Tanyell Waivers, Allison Janney.
Rated R. Universal Pictures. USA. 99 mins.