dir. Laura Murphy
Three men. One killer. Too many alibis that sound like pickup lines. On her 30th birthday, Eva gets dumped by her long-term boyfriend and does what every emotionally disoriented millennial is supposed to: downloads a dating app. Somewhere between the hangover and the profile pic upload, her favorite true-crime podcast starts covering a serial killer who meets women the same way. The killer, we’re told, has no fingerprints, a forensic background, and an off-putting fondness for wine. She lines up three dates. Kyle, who sips rosé and talks like he’s already prepping the anniversary slideshow. Mitch, a bar owner whose kitchen accident allegedly cost him his fingerprints. And Norman, a security guy who drops forensic trivia like someone still trying to ace the midterm. None of them seem dangerous—just dangerously plausible. At first, Eva goes through the motions. But as the podcast rolls out new theories, her dating history starts to feel more curated than coincidental. She keeps seeing all three. Flirtations get second-guessed. Memories rerun with new emphasis. Compliments get cross-examined. Her instincts don’t sharpen—they shift. The setup is sharp, the conceit neat. But once the film lands its central twist—that one of these men is the killer but there’s no way to be sure who—the tension levels out. Eva cycles through her suspicions like a rerouted sitcom plot, and the story drifts into a steady, low-level loop. The laughs keep coming, but nothing cuts deep. Lucy Hale plays Eva with easy, low-key likability—sharp enough to carry the premise, relaxed enough to let it play out. The tone stays breezy, never pushing too hard in any direction. And while the film doesn’t build to much, it does hold together: a sly, mildly warped genre exercise that lets its satire peek through without overplaying its hand. F*** Marry Kill doesn’t go for the jugular—but it has fun poking around the ribs.
Starring: Lucy Hale, Virginia Gardner, Brooke Nevin, Samer Salem, Bethany Brown, Jedidiah Goodacre, Brendan Morgan.
Rated R. Lionsgate Premiere. USA. 97 mins.